Midnight Mysteries-One Body Too Many (1944)
Eager beaver insurance salesman, Albert Tuttle, thinks he’s landed a dream appointment with eccentric millionaire, Cyrus Rutherford. He arrives at the Rutherford estate only to find his hot prospect is stone cold dead with a house full of conniving relatives, suspicious servants and a slippery lawyer. As stipulated in Rutherford’s will, none of the potential heirs may leave the premises until the next morning. It could be the opportunity of a lifetime for Tuttle…if he lives through the night.
One Body Too Many is the typical creepy mansion flick complete with secret rooms and hidden passages as well as a comic twist. While likeable Tuttle is hardly the typical stoic, square-jawed hero he stammers, stumbles and scrambles from one situation to the next. Though the large cast makes it tough to distinguish the cut-throat relatives from one another, the flick is well-worth a watch.
Director Frank McDonald worked on the railroad prior to his directing career. He directed more than 100 films including action movies and Westerns.
Albert Tuttle was played by Jack Haley who is best known for his role as the Tin Man in the Wizard of Oz.
Bela Lugosi appeared in a supporting role as Merkel the butler.